Fantasy Index

header banner img
OUR FANTASY BASEBALL MAGAZINE IS BACK! PRE-ORDER NOW
Win here.

Factoid

Aaron Rodgers

Is age just a number?

In general, I'm in on Aaron Rodgers this season. I think the new Jets quarterback will be playing with a chip on his shoulder, which has worked out for other older elite quarterbacks changing teams. And I think he can still play. But I'm not sure he's going to be able to do it for more than one season, and even for 2023, I can't help but wondering how much he has left.

Rodgers turned 39 during the season, so he'll celebrate his 40th birthday during 2023. It's an age that has seen very few top seasons from quarterbacks -- even fewer if you do nothing more than leave out Tom Brady.

Since 1970, there have been 26 times when a quarterback 39 or older has started at least half the season. About 30 percent of those players (8) finished with top-10 fantasy seasons (1 point for every 20 passing and 10 rushing yards, 4-point TD passes and 6-point TD runs). Half of them (4) were Tom Brady.

Warren Moon (twice), Brett Favre and Drew Brees are the other guys to do it. In 53 years. In the table, those top-10 seasons are in bold.

OLDER QUARTERBACKS (39-PLUS) STARTING 8-PLUS GAMES
YearPlayerAgeGSCmpAttYdsTDIntPPRRk
2022Tom Brady, T.B.45174907334694259344.610
2022Aaron Rodgers, G.B.391735054236952612308.213
2021Tom Brady, T.B.441748571953164312457.93
2021Ben Roethlisberger, Pitt.391639060537402210285.521
2020Tom Brady, T.B.431640161046334012410.37
2020Philip Rivers, Ind.391636954341692411305.720
2020Drew Brees, N.O.41122753902942246254.922
2019Tom Brady, N.E.42163736134057248322.315
2019Drew Brees, N.O.40112813782979274262.625
2018Tom Brady, N.E.411637557043552911350.913
2018Drew Brees, N.O.39153644893992325356.99
2017Tom Brady, N.E.40163855814577328363.73
2016Tom Brady, N.E.39122914323554282298.121
2015Peyton Manning, Den.3991983312249917147.931
2015Matt Hasselbeck, Ind.408156256169095122.035
2010Brett Favre, Min.411321735825091119170.328
2009Brett Favre, Min.40163635314202337343.67
2008Brett Favre, NYJ391634352234722222274.111
2004Vinny Testaverde, Dall.411529749535321720256.416
2001Doug Flutie, S.D.391629452134641518258.417
1998Warren Moon, Sea.42101452581632118128.628
1997Warren Moon, Sea.411431352836782516293.97
1996Warren Moon, Min.408134247161079109.135
1995Warren Moon, Min.391637760642283314351.63
1986Jim Plunkett, Oak.3981332521986149160.022
1974Len Dawson, K.C.3981382351573713109.524

Rodgers himself just missed the top-10 as a 39-year-old, finishing 13th among quarterbacks last year. With better overall receiving weapons with the Jets -- although actually, a couple of the same ones -- maybe he can sneak onto it in 2023.

But I'm expecting a short shelf life. I think he's got a year or two left, tops.

--Andy Richardson

Fantasy Index