Fantasy Index

Andy Richardson

A Day of Football

The fantasy playoffs often offer up reminders of how much of a game of inches this is. Starting Carson Palmer, as I was in two playoff leagues? It was tough to see John Brown drop a pair of touchdowns and Michael Floyd catch a bomb at the one-foot line, costing Palmer 2-3 additional scores. Facing Palmer or starting David Johnson? You probably made out well.

That kind of stuff you have no control over. You hope you made the right lineup choices, and try not to feel bad if luck went against you. Maybe you won anyway, or maybe it went your way last year. Or will next year.

Kansas City at Ravens: Pretty good game for most of the correct players in this one. Charcandrick West had a breakaway touchdown run early, and Jeremy Maclin caught a touchdown. Nice when favorable predictions pan out. On the other hand, Javorius Allen lost a fumble early, it was returned for a touchdown, and Allen was benched. Seemed OK as a feature back for a team with limited offensive weaponry, but a miscue changed all that. That touchdown, by the way, was one of a pair by the Kansas City Defense. Kamar Aiken had a big game, helped along by a Hail Mary before the half defended as poorly as the Green Bay one two weeks back. Maybe teams should work more on those.

Texans at Colts: Thought Houston would do a little more on offense here. Wrong. Didn't know T.J. Yates would get hurt, but Brandon Weeden was similar. And Yates done for the year and Hoyer (concussion) uncertain, so Weeden -- who began the year as a backup in Dallas -- might be starting for a Division Champion Texans team. ... Alfred Blue over 100 yards, but he's a pretty unremarkable back. Lost an early fumble. Had a long run that some backs score on. He's a guy. Donte Moncrief caught a touchdown in this game, a guy you couldn't really use with him iffy with an injury prior to the game. Near TD for Coby Fleener, couldn't hang on. Jaelen Strong caught game-winning TD; all his 3 scores this year against Colts. Andrew Luck may need to play next week if he wants to play in a meaningful game again this year.

Falcons at Jaguars: Hope you're in a PPR league if you started Denard Robinson. There, he was fine; not so much in standard. Frustrating too, because right before the half Bortles had him wide open in the center of the end zone for an easy little touchdown. Instead he threw a pass toward the side of the end zone, it was picked off and nearly brought back for a half-ending touchdown. (Bortles, to his credit, made the game-saving tackle.) Week after week Bortles makes these throws he just shouldn't. He has been a great fantasy quarterback this year, but if he wants to keep it up he needs to eliminate the bone-headed mistakes. ... Devonta Freeman caught a pass near the goal line early on, then had a nice touchdown run. That was essentially the bulk of his production, but he didn't hurt you. Nice game for Julio Jones, too. Decent numbers for Julius Thomas, although he had his hand on a touchdown that he couldn't bring in. Oh, and then Bortles missed an open Allen Hurns in the final minute for (probably) a game-winning touchdown. Difference between winning and losing.

Bears at Vikings: An unusual game, but the result was expected. Just rather than Adrian Peterson having a big game, Teddy Bridgewater and Stefon Diggs did. Couple of perfect throws by Bridgewater, a nice tackle-breaking run by Diggs on on one score. Peterson also got hurt, during the game, limping off and taking most teams fantasy hopes with him. He returned, but might have been hurt. Sounds like he'll play next week. Jerick McKinnon had a tackle-breaking TD reception after Peterson left. Alshon Jeffery and Matt Forte caught TDs. Some nice throws by Jay Cutler in defeat, but Minnesota got a lot of pressure on him. Jeffery injured a hamstring, so expect another week of questionable status and "he has a chance to play."

Titans at Patriots: Delanie Walker scored 2 TDs in this game, one a ridiculous long tackle-breaking one that should have been just a short reception. He was the only Titan you should have been starting. That said, Dorial Green-Beckham had some very nice garbage-time stats, so you made out OK if you dared to use him. Rob Gronkowski caught his touchdown early. James White caught one, screen pass. Brandon Bolden showed the risk in starting a committee back, since New England gave more carries to recently promoted practice squad fullback Joey Iosefa. Quick reaction, leave him on the waiver wire. Danny Amendola hurt early. Knee. We'll see. Decent game for Brandon LaFell, though he didn't score. Patriots D touchdown, so they worked out. Marcus Mariota hurt, offense didn't lose anything this injury go-around with Zach Mettenberger.

Panthers at Giants: So, great game. I remember when the score was 35-7, looking at the TV and saying, well, that's that, and then, huh, there's a lot of time left in this game. Giants came all the way back with touchdowns by Tye, Vereen, Jennings and finally Odell Beckham Jr., who had previously had a horrific day which began by dropping a 52-yard touchdown and further devolved into several meltdown cheapshots exchanged back and forth with Josh Norman. (The worst by Beckham, you've no doubt seen the lowlights.) There were a couple of turnovers and a blocked Carolina field goal in there. But Cam Newton marched Carolina right down the field with arm and legs for a game- and MVP-winning score. Another big, 2-TD game for Ted Ginn Jr. (who also dropped another touchdown). Running back committee did nothing of consequence. Greg Olsen scored and had a huge catch on the game-winning drive. Giants are going to be a good team that misses the playoffs, it appears, having blown too many games along the way. Well, their defense is terrible.

Bills at Washington: Big games by a lot of big players. Early TD for Jordan Reed, just a jump ball where he easily beat the defender. Later in the half, he scores again, largely uncovered. Remember loving him when he came out but kind of gave up on him with all the injuries. So, good for him. Also Kirk Cousins, who I really didn't believe in. Washington might well win the NFC East, and Cousins is the guy making it happen. Impressive. ... Big game also for Sammy Watkins, a disappointment earlier in the season but huge right now. On the other hand, LeSean McCoy disappointed and left with an injury, as happens a lot. Stuffed at the goalline on back to back plays before leaving with an injury, touchdown there would have helped Buffalo's cause. Both Karlos Williams and Mike Gillislee looking good in relief, too.

Packers at Raiders: Raiders have made some steps this year, but evidently aren't quite ready to win this game. Early Pick Six by Derek Carr stuck them in a 14-0 hole they briefly dug their way out of, but not for long. Green Bay moved the ball up and down the field; but for some penalties and turnovers and settling for field goals, it wouldn't have been quite as close. Among the penalties, offensive interference calls on James Jones, one negating a touchdown. ... Nice game for Amari Cooper, decent ones for Crabtree and Carr. Raiders host Chargers next week and should put up good numbers (San Diego spent the rest of its effort this season in final home game, methinks).

Browns at Seahawks: Cleveland was more competitive than I expected, for a while. But then Seattle got interested in the game, Russell Wilson threw another pair of touchdowns to Doug Baldwin, and even Jermaine Kearse had a big game. Fantasy-wise, the bigger story is that Christine Michael took hold of the Seattle backfield. Michael was released from the Washington practice squad last week, and you have to wonder whether he couldn't have helped Washington or Dallas at some point this season; instead he's there to probably lead the Seattle backfield the rest of the way. Neither he nor Bryce Brown scored, but Michael looks like the guy.

Broncos at Steelers: Great first half for the Broncos, great second half for the Steelers. There is just no stopping that Steelers offense right now; it only seems to happen if their defense scores (like last week) or just keeps the other team in check. Although Brock Osweiler struggled in the second half, I came away pretty impressed with him. For one thing, he was again victimized by terrible drops of perfect throws that would have picked up first downs late, one awful one by Vernon Davis (again) and one by Demaryius Thomas (again). Meanwhile Emmanuel Sanders had about the game of his life against his former team, making great catches all over the place. Denver loses, my son is bummed, but I think they'll beat Cincinnati in Denver next week and get the edge for that other first-round bye.

Dolphins at Chargers: Four TDs for Danny Woodhead (3 receiving), who probably no one started since he hasn't done anything for half a season. But we were higher on Philip Rivers than even I expected and it proved to be a great call by Ian. Started him over Matt Ryan and Jay Cutler, worked out well. Melvin Gordon left early with a knee injury and it's saying something that Donald Brown finished with better numbers than Gordon would no doubt have delivered. Brown might start here next week if the Gordon injury serious, which would just be the perfect capper to his disappointing season. Dolphins can't wait for season to end and another housecleaning to begin.

Bengals at 49ers: Worklmanlike win on the ground for the Bengals, with A.J. Green leaving early with a back injury. Touchdown for Tyler Kroft on a nice little play, something to keep in mind if Tyler Eifert can't return next week. All of San Francisco's offense was in garbage-time, and Shaun Draughn left with an injury.

Cardinals at Eagles: As noted, Palmer and the Cardinals passing game could have had a much bigger game. John Brown dropped perfectly thrown balls on Arizona's first two drives that would have gone for short and long touchdowns. Michael Floyd just missed one. And then there's Larry Fitzgerald, who after his early-season flurry of scoring now seems to be the clear No. 3 wideout in this passing game. ... Some nice garbage-time production from the Eagles, who host Washington next Saturday. I think the way they've used or misused their running backs will be one of the key storylines if and when they miss the playoffs.

Monday, Monday: I and many others in playoff games will be glued to this one tonight. Starting Tim Hightower and Golden Tate! Facing Drew Brees! Starting Calvin Johnson, with Lance Moore at the ready just in case Johnson is inactive or limping obviously in pregame warmups. Hopefully Johnson on one leg is good enough to light up this defense. Am expecting lots of yards and points and probably a 28-24 Saints win, or something similar. Good luck to all.

20 Reader Comments:

Scott Anderson

Lakewood, CO
2015-12-21T15:24:33Z
Last year, made playoffs in 3 of 4 leagues, went 0-3 in Week 15. This year, made playoffs in 3 of 4 leagues...have already lost 2 and need some heroics tonight to avoid going 0-3 again. I've had less fun this year than I have in many many years of playing fantasy. Last night I went to bed wishing that I didn't even play this frustrating, random game. Next year we are having our 20th draft in Vegas, and right now it sounds like a horrible time. More often than not fantasy just sucks the joy out of simply watching a good football game...makes me wonder about the future of the hobby.

DAVID DIGREGORIO

Norristown, PA
2015-12-21T15:24:36Z
I think that was the 6th game the Giants lost in the last 2 minutes or in OT. Amazing.

Matt Mumford

Tillamook, OR
2015-12-21T15:27:12Z
Nice recap, Andy! Started David Johnson and he did not disappoint! Put me in the championship game!!

Roy Sherman

Columbia, TN
2015-12-21T15:49:33Z
Thanks for the advice on the Chiefs defense. Every spot in my starting lineup scored in double digits, with my QB, both WRs, and my D getting over 20. Assuming Watson doesn't score 69 points tonight, I'll be playing in the championship game next week. Thanks again for all of your advice during the year.

Jeffrey Martin

Ellington, CT
2015-12-21T16:12:21Z
Sat down Jeremy Hill to play Javorius Allen, based on the rankings and Saturday comments. Lost by 11 - C'est la guerre.

BEN HOGEVOLL

Siletz, OR
2015-12-21T16:45:06Z
Scott Remember this is a stupid game played by a bunch of nerds!Dont think of suicide for god sakes and also remember,you are not the one on the field.At least you and I are not in front of the world playing star war games with a battery powered plastic sword.Now thoughs people are the real idiots.

Christopher Coulson

Mission Hills, KS
2015-12-21T17:11:28Z
Played against Cam Newton and his 60+ pts fueled by last second scramble to get to EXACTLY 100 yards (bonus). Also against Aiken fueled by a career game with Hail Mary.... Also against Sanders and his 40+ pt game just a week after he scored 1 point...
.... And still will likely win tonight unless Stafford goes for -3 points. So lucky! I lead 209-207 with all my players going for well over 20 pts led by Antonio.

Scott Anderson

Lakewood, CO
2015-12-21T17:21:52Z
It's cool Ben, I'm fine. Not suicidal, haha. I think I've just been playing this for too long. The game today with smartphones, RBBC, DraftKings EVERYWHERE, rand ridiculous scoring systems just makes me pine for the days of yore, when you'd call in your lineup to an answering machine & compute scores out of Monday's USA Today. Today's game is such a timesuck. I miss just being able to sit down & enjoy a football game!

Scott Anderson

Lakewood, CO
2015-12-21T17:23:33Z
And good one about the Star Wars crowd, although I did go see it yesterday (during the Bronco game, hoping that would thin the crowds here in Denver. It did not.) Glad I saw it before the spoilers leaked everywhere.

CRAIG APANA

Ewa Beach, HI
2015-12-21T18:40:46Z
But on the other hand for some like me, it was WONDERFUL to watch John Brown drop a pair of touchdowns. Golden Tate needs to nail it for me tonight.

Jane Williams

Wooster, OH
2015-12-21T18:47:06Z
In one league I started out by losing Amendola (-2 points) and McCoy. Thought I was done, but I had David Johnson! I still have a good chance unless Stafford goes crazy tonight.

JON S

Coon Rapids, MN
2015-12-21T19:13:40Z
To Scott Anderson:
I think you bring up a great subject for Ian and Andy to write about. Yes Fantasy football is/has/will change on a yearly basis, but some of us "old fogies" have been playing for 20+ years. What do they miss about the NFL and Fantasy Football from the olden days ????
I loved your comment about reading the USA Today. Always remember how excited you kind of had to be to see the Monday morning paper for stats !!!!

Adam Bjork

Savage, MN
2015-12-21T19:38:00Z
Not too much longer and kids will wonder what a USA Today is. .5 PPR, anyone think cooks can score 56? Not likely but I'll take the production from Brees who needs 18 to win against team with John Brown :)

Andrew Paterson

Ferndale, WA
2015-12-21T19:42:45Z
Ditto to Scott and Jon S comments. Getting up early Monday morning to pour over the sports pages, and getting partial results from watching NFL Primetime with Chris Berman, made things exciting. Nowadays, with all the information on-line, research and preparation time seem devalued.

jim toon

2015-12-21T20:16:33Z
played Buck Allen over Mcfadden, E Sanders, based on rankings cost me Championship game =C'est la guerre. for me too

Joseph Varnon

Houston, TX
2015-12-22T08:21:31Z
sweet - I just lost 98.68 - 98.66 because of the last play saints dumpoff to Hightower, who instead of lateraling just tried to get as much as he could
just enough to beat me

what an awesome game for my opponent

ANDY RICHARDSON

Port Chester, NY
2015-12-22T11:55:02Z
Lost in one league because of hightowers negated TD. Lost in another with Calvins no show versus Brees huge second half. Sometimes this game is no fun. Had Palmer in both and feared it could happen.

Bob Shooey

2015-12-22T14:59:15Z
Totally agree with Scott's comments. Even when I win in one league I'm losing in heartbreak fashion in another. Might be time to retire when it starts leading to sleepless nights. Let me know if anyone has organized a Fantasy Footballers Anonymous yet.

JOHN RUPPE

Fort Myers, FL
2015-12-22T17:20:02Z
Didn't play David Johnson and his 46 points in ppr league. Didn't play Cam, instead Palmer, and his 41 points in standard yardage league. But the Fantasy Gods were smiling on me and I won both! Don't think I've ever won two games where I sat the highest scoring player. 2 Championship games this week and I'm already looking st some good money. Thank goodness Brandi Cooks has turned into the WR we all were expecting at the beginning of the season

Rocky Petrella

Philadelphia, PA
2015-12-22T23:37:44Z
Dynasty league where I had Rivers, Julio, Hopkins, Gurley, and Gronk. Lost by 1.12 points to mediocre team that happened to have great matchups across the board, topped by Stafford against the Saints last night. Needed him to be held to 21.86. Got 22.98. Been playing fantasy in same league since 2004 and most years at least one other league. Almost always in the playoffs. STILL have never won the whole thing. I swear I'm cursed somehow.
Sign in to add a comment

Fantasy Index